When it comes to police work, certain breeds come to mind as the go-to choices: German Shepherds, Belgian Malinois, and Belgian Tervuren, to name a few. These breeds are commonly used for various law enforcement duties like tracking suspects, searching for drugs or explosives, and crowd control. However, one breed that might seem like an ideal candidate—thanks to its impressive physicality, loyalty, and intelligence—is the Doberman. So why is the Doberman not used as a police dog, especially when it has so many traits that seem perfect for such work?
In this article, we’ll explore the qualities that make the Doberman a great dog but also discuss the reasons why it isn’t commonly used in police work. From temperament and history to its physical traits, we’ll cover everything you need to know about the Doberman’s role in law enforcement (or lack thereof).
The Doberman: A Brief Overview
The Doberman is a medium-to-large dog known for its sleek, muscular build and alert, intelligent demeanor. It was originally bred in Germany by a man named Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann in the late 19th century. Dobermann, who was a tax collector, needed a dog that would provide protection and be strong enough to help with his work. The result was a breed known for its loyalty, intelligence, strength, and protective nature. These traits made the Doberman highly regarded as a personal protection dog.
Over the years, the Doberman has been used in various roles, including as guard dogs, military dogs, and even therapy dogs. They are known for their obedience, speed, and the ability to learn complex tasks quickly. However, despite these strong qualities, they are not the top choice for police work.
Key Traits of the Doberman
Before delving into why they are not commonly used by law enforcement, let’s take a look at the Doberman’s strengths that make them an impressive breed.
1. Intelligence and Trainability
The Doberman is highly intelligent, ranking among the top dog breeds for trainability. They are quick learners and excel at obedience training, which makes them suitable for a variety of roles, from personal protection to competitive obedience sports. They are known to respond well to positive reinforcement training, making them highly adaptable to different situations.
2. Loyalty and Protective Instincts
Dobermans are famously loyal and protective, traits that were selectively bred into them for protection purposes. They have a strong desire to protect their family or pack, which is why they are so often used as personal guard dogs. Their protective instincts can make them fearless in the face of danger, which could make them excellent candidates for roles that require courage.
3. Physical Prowess
The Doberman is a muscular, agile dog with an impressive level of stamina. These dogs are fast, strong, and well-suited for high-intensity tasks. Their sleek coats and streamlined bodies allow them to move quickly and efficiently, giving them an advantage in terms of speed during tasks like chasing suspects or navigating obstacles.
Why the Doberman Isn’t Used as a Police Dog
While the Doberman has a lot going for it, there are several reasons why this breed is not typically chosen as a police dog. Let’s take a closer look at the factors that play a role in making the Doberman a less-than-ideal candidate for police work.
1. Temperament and Aggression
One of the primary reasons the Doberman isn’t widely used in police work is its temperament. While Dobermans are loyal and protective, they can also be more temperamental than other breeds like the German Shepherd. Their protective instincts can sometimes cause them to be overly aggressive or suspicious of strangers, especially if they aren’t properly socialized from a young age.
In police work, dogs need to be able to differentiate between threats and non-threats. A dog that is overly aggressive or easily triggered can cause issues during operations where split-second decisions need to be made. The Doberman’s tendency to be somewhat more territorial and aggressive can make it difficult for trainers to ensure the dog can remain calm and controlled in high-stress situations.
2. Overprotectiveness and Independence
While the Doberman’s protective nature is one of its key strengths, it can also be a hindrance in police work. Dobermans are known to form strong bonds with their handlers, which can make them overly protective and potentially difficult to control when not in training. This overprotectiveness can become a problem if the dog perceives a potential threat where there is none, leading to unnecessary aggression.
Furthermore, Dobermans are independent thinkers, which, while useful in certain situations, can be a challenge for police work. Police dogs need to be highly responsive to their handler’s commands, even under pressure. The Doberman’s tendency to act on its own intuition might lead to unpredictable behavior, making it harder to control during critical moments.
3. Health and Longevity Concerns
Another factor that works against the Doberman in police work is its health and lifespan. Dobermans have a relatively short life expectancy compared to other working dog breeds, often living around 10 to 12 years. Additionally, they are prone to certain health issues, such as hip dysplasia, heart problems (including dilated cardiomyopathy), and bloat, which can make them less reliable for the physically demanding tasks involved in police work.
4. Size and Physical Traits
The Doberman is a relatively large dog, but it’s still smaller than the German Shepherd or Belgian Malinois, which are often preferred for police work. The larger size of these breeds makes them more imposing and effective in situations like crowd control or apprehending suspects. Their size also makes them more suited for tasks that involve physical strength, such as subduing a person in a confrontational situation.
While Dobermans are agile and fast, their slightly smaller build compared to other police dog breeds may limit their effectiveness in situations where a larger, stronger dog is required. The larger size of breeds like the German Shepherd and Belgian Malinois also allows them to perform tasks like tracking over longer distances with more stamina and endurance.
5. Prejudices and Stereotypes
Over the years, Dobermans have garnered a reputation for being dangerous or aggressive, largely due to their portrayal in the media. While Dobermans are, in reality, no more dangerous than other breeds, their reputation has led to a bias against them in certain roles, including police work.
In some areas, Dobermans are seen as too aggressive or difficult to train, even though these traits are often the result of improper handling and lack of socialization. These stereotypes can sometimes deter law enforcement agencies from considering Dobermans as a viable option for police work, even though, with proper training, they could excel.
Are There Any Advantages to Using the Doberman in Police Work?
-
Excellent Protection Abilities – Dobermans are outstanding guard dogs. Their loyalty and natural protective instincts make them well-suited for situations where a police officer needs an additional layer of protection.
-
High Intelligence and Trainability – Dobermans are highly intelligent dogs that can excel in specialized tasks, such as tracking or search-and-rescue operations. Their intelligence allows them to quickly learn and adapt to new commands, which could make them highly effective in specialized police units.
-
Great Agility and Speed – Dobermans are incredibly fast and agile, which can be an asset in situations that require quick movement or agility, such as chasing down suspects in open areas or navigating obstacles.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the Doberman is an incredibly intelligent, loyal, and protective breed, it is not commonly used as a police dog for a variety of reasons. Its temperament, independence, health concerns, and physical traits often make other breeds, such as the German Shepherd or Belgian Malinois, more suitable for police work.
That being said, the Doberman is still a highly versatile and capable dog that excels in personal protection and specialized roles. If properly trained, a Doberman could certainly perform well in certain aspects of law enforcement, but it is simply not the first choice for most police forces around the world.
If you’re considering a Doberman as a family dog or for a different specialized role, they can make an excellent companion and protector. However, for police departments, other breeds may be more practical due to the specific needs of the job.